Chinese Censors Tighten the Screws on Television and Social Media

Well I am on a role talking about China on this blog! There have been two disturbing developments this week in Chinese government’s media censorship campaign, as discussed in articles in The Australian and The Financial Times. The first development is that the government has indicated that it will move to gain greater control over microblogs. These sites somewhat resemble Twitter, which is banned in China. Currently microblogs are one of the few outlets for free expression and government dissent in China. According to The Australian, “It is the only widely connected public forum in the Communist Party state and the sites are regularly used to make comments about government departments, officials and other authorities.” It is said that the government will soon require companies offering microblogging services to obtain government licenses. One would suppose that these licensed companies would have to impose stringent censorship on its users’ blogs in order to stay in business. The chief executive of the very popular Chinese microblogging site Sina has already said it is implementing “more mechanisms to quash rumors.”

Both articles also mention the Chinese government’s new initiative to purge Chinese television of “vulgar” shows. One show that has been cancelled as part of this purge is Super Girl, a hugely popular (400 million viewers!) talent show series where  the audience votes for the winners. While the Chinese government accuses the show of being profane, critics feel the real reason for cancellation is that the government feels threatened by democratic process featured on the show. Not having seen the show myself, I cannot comment on the vulgarity of its content, but I strongly suspect that the voting element is the real cause for offense. Hunan Satellite TV says it has “agreed to replace Super Girl with programs that “promote moral ethics, public safety and housework.” (Housework? Seriously?!)

How long can this censorship go on? When I wrote a report on “The Great Firewall of China” back in 2008, my conclusion was that while there are ways around the internet firewall, and people do use these methods, most Chinese citizens are content to visit the websites that are available to them. Now, however, I suspect the tides may be turning.  Will the 400 million fans of Super Girl fail to notice that one of their favorite shows have been cancelled for no good reason? Sure, pop culture is known for its short memory, but Chinese youth will probably not be satisfied if their only options on television are government-produced news shows or the Chinese equivalent of “Leave It to Beaver.”  Far from keeping Chinese youth loyal, a lack of media they can relate to may lead them to seek out foreign media that features far more subversive themes than a talent contest. Likewise, from a purely strategic point of view, I think the Chinese government is using poor judgement in upping its censorship of microblogs. These blogs let people blow off a bit of steam against the government. Attempts to stifle this may cause increased anger and push resistance underground where it will be harder to monitor and respond to. These increased controls indicate to me that the Chinese government is very concerned right now about losing control, but I think these overly stringent policies may harm their cause rather than help it.

What do you all think of the Chinese government’s new policies? Do you think they will succeed in dampening free speech and pushes for increased democracy in China? Or do you think these policies will engender resistance?



The Australian- “Censors kill Super Girl as bloggers muzzled

The Financial Times- “Censors kill off China’s ‘Super Girl’


One thought on “Chinese Censors Tighten the Screws on Television and Social Media

  1. Frankly, the censorship acts remind me of Pleasantville, the movie where Reese Witherspoon ‘corrupts’ everybody by exposing them to the world outside. I agree with you, Tory, by censoring certain shows, it isn’t like they’re showing that they’re promoting those values: most teenagers will not recognize that. Furthermore, I think by promoting only certain values, it enforces the fact that we will continue to have problems within the genders (some who think it’s unfair, others who don’t mind/notice the censorship) and between them too. Through the use of this censorship, I’m not sure that nationalism will come about. Tory, I once took a course on censorship in the media in general (and then we focused on other countries as well), what do you think about censorship as it plays out? Do you think that censorship is always good, or always bad, or do you think it just depends on the circumstance?
    – Tara

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at

%d bloggers like this: